Replace Sewer Line Or Water Supply Lines?

Ted profile photo

Hello

I manage a 15 unit building that has previously gotten bids for replacing the sewer P-traps, and lines from the building to the city sewer; as well as replacing the horizontal supply lines.

The problem is...we can only afford to do one or the other. The sewer lines are under concrete, and a couple of the units can smell sewer gas in their unit. The supply lines are old lead pipes with drip leaks in a couple of spots.

I realize that this is not enought information to fully evaluate, but I would like to hear what everyone thinks...which one should be replaced first?


Thanks very much!

Ted

Comments(5)

  • DavidBrowne14th September, 2003

    ok Ted I'll try anything once how is this solution. Trap off the sewer line at the point of exit in the basement. that will stop the oder from coming in as long as the trap holds water.
    Then fix the pressure line

  • terrapin7th October, 2003

    terst

  • benny2227th October, 2003

    Hi Ted,

    I am in Chicago and can help you out. I have a couple of contractors who specialize in plumbing and are very reasonable. If you are interested email me and I can have you in contact with them.

    Benny
    [addsig]

  • mussetter7th October, 2003

    I know of a company in Ohio that, instead of digging up and replacing sewage lines, can run a hard plastic 'liner' through. They only have to have access at either end and it's about 1/2 of the cost. Maybe you can do that and some of the plumbing.

    Hope this helps.

    Ronnie

    [addsig]

  • jpchapboy8th October, 2003

    all I can say is DYI hire some neighbor kids to dig a trench or rent a Ditch-Witch and dig a trnech to the street. you may be able to get the water company to replace the old water meter for free. (they own it and may be more than willing to replace it if it is out-dated as a preventitive maintanance deal) When they have a big hole there you can get to the supply at the street (ask them to not bury it agin) the Ditch-Witch can dig a 3' deep trench and unless you have to go 200' from the street to the building it should only take a couple hours. Home Depot rents them for around $40-$60 for 4 hours (pretty sure) then the pipe won't cost too much. I don't have a clue how deep the sewer is but the pipe is relatively cheap. New supply lines are wonderful. Also if you really have lead supply pipes I would DEFINATLY replace them or you will have health issues to deal with. The local Health Department could potentially condemn your building for that. Are you sure they aren't galvanized steel pipes? Good luck.
    Josh

Add Comment

Login To Comment