A Quick Comparison of Real Estate Investing Business Entities

stockpro99 profile photo

A QUICK COMPARISON OF SEVERAL BUSINESS ENTITIES



Asset Protection

Between 80 & 100 million lawsuits are filed each year & you have a 5 times greater chance of being sued than you do of going to the hospital for major illness or injury this year. The reasons for these suits are endless, sexual harassment form an employee. Discrimination; because you mentioned “you prefer married couples” to prospective renters. The couple you rent to cooks meth, catches the house on fire and burns the neighbors house down too. A deal goes south and the other party thinks you owe them something… The name of the game is to protect what you have worked so hard for from people that “want something for nothing”, your money…





Sole Proprietor



This is the most common business entity. It requires virtually no paperwork to start doing business in this fashion. It offers “no” protection from lawsuits, and has the most limited/poor tax benefits. There are no allowances for fringe benefits etc. If a tenant slips on the stairs at your property, or your business is sued you have no protection whatsoever for your personal assets. You and the business are the same and all your assets are at risk..



Partnerships



Even worse than a Sole Proprietor, you are held liable for anything stupid your partner does. If he files bankruptcy you can be held liable under the doctrine of joint and several liabilities. Use a case by case “Joint Venture” agreement, LLC, C, S, Corp. rather than a long term partnership agreement.





Corporations



Corporations require more paperwork to start up and manage but can easily be set up by the individual (however I say why go through the hassle? Pay the $100 for any of a number of companies on the web to do it for you. http://www.corpco.com http://www.sbincorporationservices.com you get the idea).

Where in an SP you and the business are the same person and everything is exposed, a corporation is a person created by law and its own entity. When proper procedures are maintained there is a shield between you and your personal assets. Creditors are limited to the assets of the corporation.

Certain formalities should be maintained to keep your corporate protection strong and keep creditors from piercing the corporate veil. Discuss this with your attorney & do further research for yourself.

At a minimum you should do the following (I didn’t the first time I set up an entity and fortunately was not called on it).



1. Fill out a corporate minute book.

2. Elect board of directors/officers.

3. Issue stock certificates

4. Obtain EIN# from IRS

5. Open bank account In Corporation’s name.

6. Hold yearly shareholder meeting (over lunch with your wife )

7. Have a physical office & lease (your garage, bedroom, den,)

8. Have your phone in the corporation’s name.

9. Get licensing in corporation’s name.

10. Be funded sufficiently for doing business on day to day basis.

11. Make sure you sign everything as an officer of the corporation i.e. Joe Investor “president” always designating your corporate capacity.



This can all be done in about 2-3 hours a year. I would suggest further reading on these entities or purchasing a course www.legalwhiz.com you might find a used one on Ebay. From the research I have done William Bronchick is a leading authority on asset protection and tax law for real estate investors. Talking over your structure etc. with a CPA and lawyer is always a good idea.



There are two types of Corporations “S” & “C” I shall give a very brief look at them and list only a few of the advantages. Do some reading and get competent help from your CPA/Attorney.



A “C” corporation files a tax return and pays taxes on its profits. The “C” corporation then distributes dividends to the shareholders (avoid taking profits in a C corp. this way to avoid double taxation). A C corporation offers the most tax benefits if you are doing enough business to justify the expense.



Benefits: Protection of personal assets and liability from acts as director of corporation-privacy-deductible life insurance plan for $50,000- deductible dental medical plan- deductible premiums for disability insurance- 1 person required to incorporate-tons of deductible “fringe benefits” like pizza in the workplace when working after hours (did I mention that your den can be your workplace/office? See above).



An “S” corp. is treated like a partnership for tax purposes and files a K-1. Unlike a “C” corp. you want to take profits in the form of dividends to avoid the 15.4% self employment tax. A huge benefit.



Benefits: S corp. losses can be deducted against ordinary personal income in excess of $50,000 per year(like a spousal income)-Reduce payroll taxes by reducing salary to lowest reasonable amount and taking profits in dividends saving 15.4% self employment tax on up to $87,000 I n 2003-Privacy-Lawsuit protection for personal assets and liability-benefits/write offs for employees-only needs one person to create.



Limited Liability Company



The newest of a breed of entities created by state statute requires filing articles of organization through the state where started. It can have 1-2 members depending on your state statutes. This files a 1065 with the IRS like a partnership. When proper procedures are maintained there is a shield between you and your personal assets.

This is the tightest entity for asset protection (in most states). This is because a member’s interest in an LLC cannot be attached by a creditor. If a creditor gets a “charging order” against you for 100k the managing partner could withhold paying you out of the LLC’s assets etc. indefinitely. After years of frustrating the creditor you could settle for less. Generally these have many of the same things that need to be done as a corporation to avoid “piercing”. In my personal opinion I think the best way to hold property is in a trust with the LLC as the beneficiary.



Land Trust’s- Intervivos



This is a great tool for the investor and owner of property. A land trust offers no protection from creditors or lawsuits outside of a corporation or LLC. What it does is remove the property out of your name on the county record books. You have the legal right to place property in trust and the bank/mortgage company has to allow you to do this. They cannot invoke DOS. In my opinion this could be an excellent way to take title in a “Subject To” deal. Look up the article on this site “What’s A Land Trust & Why You Should Remove Your Name from the Deed”.

Many lawyers don’t understand land trusts, this is good because it helps you hide what you have. When an attorney looking for “deep pockets” does a cursory asset search he will find nothing in your name. If he can’t find property with equity, insurance, etc. he will not take the case on contingency. He will probably ask for a retainer of 3-5K non refundable against his $250 an hour fee. This deters a lot of people. In the event a creditor or the IRS gets a judgment against you and places a general lien at the courthouse in your name it will not automatically attach to your properties held in trust.



Final thoughts



With the inherent risk involved of a lawsuit, and the incredible amount of money you will pay in your lifetime in taxes a fair amount of time and research should be taken to mitigate these drains on your resources.

I am not an attorney or CPA so these are my opinions and what I have learned through research and personal experience. I am sure you will teach me more that I can use in my own business.



Randall




Comments(9)

  • TheFox16th September, 2003

    Excellent article for many asking about how to mitigate risk, save on taxes, etc. Thanks!



    The Fox

  • HiPox16th September, 2003

    Very interesting information. However, I could not find the article you referred to: “What’s A Land Trust & Why You Should Remove Your Name from the Deed”. Where can I locate same? ==L==

  • Toothpick18th September, 2003

    Thanks, I was reading information of similiar concept today by R. Kiyosaki

  • Lethe30th September, 2003

    Thanks for spelling all this out. I especially like the list of things that should be done to keep a C Corp from having its veil pierced.



    If I may state that while LLC's are an excellent vehicle, it is still a relatively new entitiy and still in the process of wending it's way through the court system as to all its legal intricacies. Another entity that has been around for alot longer is the Limited Liability Partnership. Alot of the same things the LLC has but been around much longer time.



    My $.02



    Lethe

  • JohnMerchant24th October, 2003

    Great post



    Just shows what a little preplanning might do for any group(or individual) planning to buy some RE.



    Most folk never think at all about all that might happen, and proceed to buy as SPs or P'ships (unwritten ! ) and a good percentage of these do encounter legal troubles for the owners because of their poor pre-planning.

  • jcmoney31st December, 2003

    nice article but in regards to the land trust and having a property held by a corporation name the owner is still responsible

    for mortgage payments. That would come up on someones credit report as an asset.

    Thanks again for the info...

    • Stockpro9931st December, 2003 Reply

      "nice article but in regards to the land trust and having a property held by a corporation name the owner is still responsible

      for mortgage payments. That would come up on someones credit report as an asset. "



      If the corporation is the owner or the LLC is the owner and you take title in an entities name then you will not be held personally liable in the event of a disaster etc. The "entity" is the owner.

      A land trust merely shields you from scrutiny.



      As for the credit report, it would show a note holder and an amount owed or paid not the property address,who has title to it, or what state it is in.

      I place "take" my personal residence in a land trust, use my brother in law in another state as the trustee and make "rent" payments to the trust who pays the mortgage.

      If I am hauled into court and tortured under oath I can truthfully say "I have no real interest in any property" regardless of the mortgage. I have a personal property interest which is my beneficial interest in the trust.

      • jcmoney1st January, 2004 Reply

        Ah, now i understand what you are talking about. Thanks for the info once again

  • Dumdido8th September, 2004

    Thank You for the very informative article. Where can I find the article you referenced: “What’s A Land Trust & Why You Should Remove Your Name from the Deed” ?



    Providing a link would be great!

    Thanks!

Add Comment

Login To Comment